You may think, from reading that title, that I was satisfied with the outcome, but that would be incorrect. I would have been fine with whatever decision coach Trent Johnson made about Malcolm White, because quite frankly, I've never doubted Johnson's class and honorable character.
Here is NOLA.com on what is hopefully the final chapter in l'affaire White:
"The decision was made real quick," Johnson said. "It was a matter of not getting caught up in what's going on on the chat boards and all that stuff in Lexington. I know what Malcom White's about and that was very disturbing what happened, but we squashed it right away and moved forward."
First of all, there is no reason for coach Johnson to listen to any of the Big Blue Nation. We have the right to our collective opinion and outrage, as applicable, but he has the right to run his team as he sees fit. If Johnson were to assure me that the suspension was unnecessary, I would have accepted that uncritically. Johnson was known as a class individual at Stanford (who would hardly hire a lout), and it's impossible for me to imagine that anything changed in the last few years.

I happen to think very highly of LSU's basketball program, always have. But my critique of the SEC's position on this matter remains unchanged, and in fact, has hardened somewhat into genuine indignity. I'm looking at you, Commissioner Slive. The comments made in connection with this matter by the SEC are unacceptable and require revision. If that means a membership vote, get it done quickly, sir. I don't see this as optional. Basketball players need protection by the league as well as the schools.
Kudos to LSU and coach Johnson for their transparency, sincerity, and muscular concern for the well-being of basketball athletes. Kudos also to White for his sincerely expressed apologies.
Razzies to the SEC for their toothless policy of non-intervention were a school to fail it's duty in this area.
0 recs | 14 comments
So I guess if AD had been able to get up quickly
and take a well-deserved swing at White, AD would have been suspended by the SEC, but not White. I think the SEC may be nearly as incompetent as the NCAA. Of course, both are way, way behind the Federal government when it comes to incompetence..
UKCat - February 3, 2012
I just do not understand why the SEC is being so " hands off" with this.....if there were revenue
involved, Mike Slive wouldn’t be able to keep his mouth shut.
Johnson has gone above and beyond his duty, the least the SEC could do is try and do theirs.
Hypocrites surround us. Why is it that when the SEC, or the NCAA, or any other governing body in college athletics make a policy, they claim that it is in the best interests of the student athletes and member institutions, but when they do nothing, they claim that their hands are tied???
Greg Alan Edwards - February 3, 2012 via Android app
BTW, Glenn.....your NOLA link comes back to ASOB.....lol
Greg Alan Edwards - February 3, 2012
Thanks for telling me.
Fixed.
Glenn Logan - February 4, 2012
Sadly
I’ve come to expect such anemic stances from both the SEC and the NCAA. Kudos to Coach Johnson for his continued integrity.
blupride - February 3, 2012
Hats off to Coach Johnson for his handling of this from the start ... maybe the SEC could take a hint
ukcris - February 3, 2012
this
Play did not deserve suspension by league. Guys come on. SEC needs to let the discipline be done by coaches and university UNLESS its horrid. This was not. One day our guy could be here. You complain about NCAA and SEC having to much power. Yet you want them to interject on this incident?
tenken - February 4, 2012 via mobile
Actually the complaint is not about having too much power as much as it is that they
do not apply that power when it should be applied.
Protecting the student-athlete should be one of, if not THE highest priority of any governing body.
These kids are amateurs, they have every right to expect that the conference and the NCAA should do everything to act in their best interests.
Unfortunately, the conference, and the NCAA are more worried about their pocketbooks and doling out ludicrous decisions where most situations are concerned.
Again, I make a call for transparency. Every dealing the SEC, NCAA or any other governing body has should be public and out there for everyone to see. That way there is no misunderstanding.
Greg Alan Edwards - February 4, 2012
This was an extremely dangerous play ...
… and was suspension-worthy. That doesn’t mean it was a slam-dunk for a suspension, and if the league had said something like:
“We reviewed the play, and decided that it wasn’t bad enough to warrant suspension.”
I would not be smacking the SEC around. Nor would I have objected if Johnson had come to the same conclusion. It is debatable, no doubt, but it is certainly worthy of suspension.
The problem is, the league has no policy to review these plays and issue suspensions if their isn’t fighting. That is wrong. There needs to be a policy about excessive rough play, even if they never have to enforce it.
The NCAA has nothing to do with this. Lumping them in is not necessary.
Glenn Logan - February 4, 2012
I agree
A lot of eyes were on this play. What they saw was:
- White lash out violently against Davis
- White’s coach deal with it
- The SEC take a pass because there was no fighting
The SEC set policy here by saying since there was no fighting, they took a pass.
The SEC should have said: “"We reviewed the play, and decided that it wasn’t bad enough to warrant suspension.” Then the policy going forward would be that incidents like this will be reviewed by the SEC and suspension will be applied, if necessary.
BlueCollarMan - February 4, 2012
Perhaps you can try to explain what horrid means
in the context of basketball fouls and what you think should be worthy of suspension.
The definitions I see all nicely describe my reaction (and my wife’s) when we saw what White did. Unless we want the game to look more like “Rollerball” (Anthony! Anthony!), there has to be a mechanism to prevent players from doing such things in every game.
My eyes still well up when I think what they did to Moonpie …
Wheatgerm - February 4, 2012
Coach Johnson handled it
it is done. Railing at the SEC is like telling waves not to land on shore.
bluecrip - February 4, 2012
I don't care.
What are blogs for if not taking up futile causes?
Glenn Logan - February 4, 2012
tell it all, brother, tell it all........
Greg Alan Edwards - February 4, 2012
You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of A Sea Of Blue to post a comment.